Expanding the NCAA Basketball Tournament to 76 teams? That way lies madness
They’re going to do it, aren’t they? History, tradition and public sentiment be damned.
They’re going to mess with success, fix what isn’t broken, add Botox and fillers to the Mona Lisa. It’s what they do, isn’t it? Not because they should. Because they can.
They’re going to expand the NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament from 68 teams to 76 teams, and they’re going to do it for the upcoming 2025-26 season. That’s the prevailing sentiment in college basketball circles. There have been too many trial balloons floated in that direction, the latest by NCAA President Charlie Baker. Never mind that every time one of those balloons goes up, it comes under heavy fire from people that love college hoops.
This is not March Madness.
It’s madness. Period.
March Madness is three extended weekends of symmetry, intensity and unpredictability, emerging and established stars sharing the same stage, underdogs taking a bite out of big dogs, all capped by One Shining Moment. It’s the quintessential college sports championship experience just the way it is.
According to @CBKReport on X, six of the top seven most-watched basketball games in 2025 were NCAA Tournament games. The other was Game 7 of the NBA Finals in which Oklahoma City pulled away from wounded Indiana in an anti-climactic clunker.
Three of the top four games on that list were Florida’s national championship comeback over Houston at No. 1, Houston’s national semifinal comeback against Duke at No. 3 and Florida’s national semifinal thriller over Auburn at No. 4.
The Elite Eight games in which Auburn pulled away from Michigan State and Duke ran away from Alabama came in at Nos. 5 and 7. Which means three of the seven most-watched basketball games of this year – college or pro – involved Auburn or Alabama.
It’s proof of concept, example number eleventy billion. Make your mark in March Madness, and a state formerly known for football only can capture the nation’s attention in roundball as well.
Actual madness is taking the proven formula that attracted all those eyeballs and tweaking it for reasons that have yet to be made clear and presented in a convincing, compelling presentation.
Should the tournament expand because the number of Division I basketball schools has increased considerably, up to 364 last season? Part of the beauty of the current long-standing format is that it maintains an optimal balance of opportunity and exclusivity.
Conference tournaments, which grab nationwide attention during Championship Week and serve as a tasty appetizer before the Big Dance, give every school a chance to play its way into the NCAA Tournament. Witness Alabama State’s inspiring run through the SWAC Tournament in March.
The Hornets played their way into the First Four, where they earned the program’s first NCAA Tournament victory with a stunning full-court Hail Mary pass and finish to beat St. Francis. That gave State a chance to put an early scare into No. 1 overall seed Auburn in the first round.
An expanded tournament won’t give us more Alabama States. It’ll give us more teams like Oklahoma and Texas, who went 6-12 in their debut seasons in the SEC but still landed NCAA at-large bids.
Remember the talking point that power conference teams that finish down in the standings need the additional bids an expanded field would provide because they’re more likely to survive and advance, like NC State 2024? The 10th-place Wolfpack had to win the ACC Tournament that year to reach the NCAA Tournament, then found a way to make it to the Final Four as an 11 seed.
Nice story, but the SEC shot down that argument in 2025. It didn’t need a 76-team field in March to shatter the old record by putting 14 teams in the NCAA Tournament field. There was enough room for Alabama State and Troy, which won the Sun Belt Tournament, as well as Texas and Oklahoma.
The 68-team field is big enough for bluebloods and new bloods, for Alabama State to complete a Hail Mary and for Johni Broome to finish off Michigan State with one arm to send Auburn to its second Final Four.
Why mess with success? Why try to improve upon the closest thing to perfection you’ll find in any postseason in any sport at any level? Why not leave well enough alone and focus all your bracket-busting energy elsewhere?
Like on the College Football Playoff. It needs all the help it can get.
Read More