Secrecy is not security: Government hides what officials fear
This column originally appeared in Kyle Whitmire’s newsletter, Alabamafication. Sign up here to get it in your inbox for free.
Donald Trump wants to hunt down and prosecute whoever leaked a US intelligence report showing his bombing raid on Iran’s nuclear program was somewhat less than “total obliteration”.
Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security is considering prosecuting CNN over an app called ICEBlock, which helps people track their activity — not because CNN made the app but simply because it reported that the app exists.
And closer to home, the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency refuses to release bodycam footage of a police officer shooting a man in Homewood, Ala., despite a law that says the family of those shot by police may see the video investigators do not object.
While these things might not seem like connected things, there’s something important that they share, something that should alarm everyone — a prevalent belief, shared by those in power, that information belongs to the government, not to the public.
Let’s take each of these, one by one.
Iran knows whether we blew up its nuclear program. They don’t need anybody to tell them. There’s no state secret lost by the New York Times and CNN reporting on what was in the Iran intelligence report, which has now been roughly corroborated by the United Nations. The reason the Trump Administration is upset is because the report contradicts what the president wants the public to believe. It embarrasses him.
The ICEBlock app lets the public watch what law enforcement is doing in public and in the name of the public. If that’s a crime, Google Maps speed trap alerts are the worst offender. And supposing that this is illegal, when did it become a further crime for media outlets to report on illegal activity? That’s not what Homeland Security is afraid of. The message here is again the same: We can watch you but you cannot watch us.
ALEA has so far refused to allow the family of 18 year-old Jabari Peoples to see video of his killing because it says releasing that footage would affect the probe. The Alabama Supreme Court has ruled that police bodycam footage is not a public record in Alabama.
Never mind that the public’s right to know is why bodycams came to be, and how Alabama mayors sold the public on them a decade ago.
Like what you see? Subscribe to my newsletter
The argument that releasing the footage somehow affects the investigation is absurd. This is not Schrodinger’s police shooting. Whether the public gets to see the video does not change what happened. It only changes what the public knows.
ALEA isn’t afraid of disrupting the investigation. ALEA is afraid of how people might react.
ICE is afraid friends and neighbors might share their feelings on the snatching of their friends.
The president is afraid of being exposed.
But here’s the thing: When the government fears the people, that’s a good thing. That means the people are in charge.
Open records and open government empower citizens to hold officials accountable, whether that’s the president of the United States bombing Iran, ICE officers sweeping the streets or suburban police officers using deadly force on a teenager.
The public has a right to know what its government is doing because public information helps protect the public from the government. Ostensibly, the government is supposed to work in the public’s name. The public is supposed to be in charge, not the other way around.
It’s as simple as that. But instead of respecting that, officials at every level are setting a tone for how they want us to live.
Knowledge is power, and power belongs only to them.
First: Tell me how I did.
Then: Subscribe to ‘Alabamafication.’ It’s free.
THIS WILL BE ON THE TEST
🥶 The check’s (not) in the mail. Abolishing the U.S. Department of Education wouldn’t hurt local schools, huh? States will get the money to spend, right? Riiiiight. A day before states were to get $7 billion in education grants, the feds informed them that the funds were frozen — including $68 million dedicated to Alabama schools.
Alabama schools to lose $68 million in federal grants under Trump freeze
[Alabama Reflector]
🙃 So it goes. I miss Kurt Vonnegut’s plain-spoken humanism as much as I miss his humor. At the Atlantic, Noah Hawley reflects on how surviving WWII shaped the sci-fi satirist’s outlook on death and life.
The making of Kurt Vonnegut’s Cat’s Cradle
[The Atlantic]
😳 The boys are not alright. A new report finds outlines a recipe for generational disaster — the cultural expectations facing young men, social isolation, a lack of economic opportunity and a multitude of predatory political opportunists lurking nearby. Nadra Nittle interviews the report author about how we fix it.
The state of American men is — not so good
[The 19th]
Kyle Whitmire is the Washington watchdog columnist for AL.com and winner of the 2023 Pulitzer Prize. a.It’s free.
If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Read More