Darius Miles: What does Michael Davis capital murder conviction mean for ex-Alabama player?
Paula Whitley made clear her office’s work wasn’t done.
Tuscaloosa County’s chief assistant district attorney had just won her case this past Friday, convincing a jury to convict Michael “Buzz” Davis of capital murder for the shooting death of Jamea Harris. Answering questions minutes after the conviction on the seventh floor of the Tuscaloosa County courthouse, Whitley expressed satisfaction with the outcome of the case. But she conveyed a message not of finality.
“We believe this is partial justice for Jamea,” Whitley said. “It’s not over.”
Whitley didn’t mention ex-Alabama basketball player Darius Miles by name, but he’s the other man charged in this case. Davis was convicted of shooting into the Jeep that carried Harris near the Strip in Tuscaloosa on Jan. 15, 2023. Davis’ attorney, John Robbins, did not successfully argue self-defense.
Miles, who has not been tried yet, was the owner of the gun. Mary Turner, Miles’ attorney, has previously stated in court that Miles provided the gun to Davis for protection.
Davis will appeal the ruling of capital murder with a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole, but the biggest question that looms after the five-day trial is: What does this mean for Miles?
Alabama Forward Darius Miles (2) dribbles the ball against Jackson State at Coleman Coliseum in Tuscaloosa, AL on Tuesday, Dec 20, 2022.
Photo by Rodger ChampionCrimson Tide Photos / UA Athleti
Darius Miles’ status
Miles has been in jail since the day of the shooting more than two years ago. Multiple times, his lawyers have tried to get Miles let out on bond. But two different judges have said no. Bond in capital murder cases is rare in Alabama.
Miles does not yet have a trial date set. That could soon change now that Davis has been found guilty.
Turner did not respond to a request for comment from AL.com after the Davis verdict.
Miles was removed from the Alabama men’s basketball team the day he was arrested.
Read more: Texts between Brandon Miller, Darius Miles before fatal shooting revealed in capital murder trial
Jamea Jonae Harris, 23, was shot to death on the Strip in Tuscaloosa. She leaves behind a 5-year-old son, Kaine. (Special to AL.com)
Will prosecution of Miles change after Davis verdict?
Now that the prosecution has a guilty verdict in hand of the shooter, Davis, will that affect how it prosecutes Miles?
“We have not given that thought at this time, since we’re just walking out of the verdict,” Whitley said Friday. “We’ll be continuing to work on his case and all the other cases that we have in the office to bring justice to all of our cases.”
Unless they hatch a plea deal, Miles will go on trial in the same courthouse with the same judge, but, with an all new jury.
Darius Miles (left) is charged with capital murder in a deadly shooting on the Strip in Tuscaloosa on Jan. 15, 2023. Michael Davis (right) has been found guilty of capital murder in that case. (Tuscaloosa County Jail)
Life without parole is the only possibility if Miles is found guilty of capital murder. The prosecution decided to take the death penalty off the table for both Davis and Miles.
Now, if Davis had been found not guilty of capital murder or the lesser manslaughter charge, then that would have had a direct impact on Miles. In that scenario, if the jury found Davis had acted in self-defense, then there might not be much of a case against Miles, who wasn’t the one who pulled the trigger.
But Davis’ trial didn’t go that way.
The Davis trial in some ways can be informative to Miles and his attorneys. Although they might not know exactly how the state will prosecute Miles, they had a full week to watch how the state prosecuted Davis. The trial also provided a week of information as to what didn’t work in trying to prove self-defense from Davis’ attorneys.
The outcome of Davis’ trial can also help inform Miles and his attorneys when weighing any potential plea agreement the prosecution might offer. But only so much. Davis was the shooter while Miles provided the gun. So their circumstances, although somewhat connected, are different and could be perceived much differently by a different jury.
What we learned about Miles’ actions on the night of the shooting
Note: These details are based on testimony from the Davis trial and surveillance video shown in court:
- Miles made plans the evening of Jan. 14, 2023 with Davis, Brandon Miller and Jaden Bradley after Alabama beat LSU. Miller and Bradley were Miles’ teammates. Davis, a friend of Miles, was not affiliated with the team.
- They met up at the Vie at University Downs apartment complex prior to going out.
- Bradley drove Davis to Twelve25 sports bar on the Strip. Miller drove Miles there, too, but the line was long, so Miller instead went to Moe’s BBQ, he testified.
- Miles, Bradley and Davis went into Twelve25 together and left once it closed.
- Miles, Bradley and Davis left the bar and walked across University Boulevard. A black Jeep Wrangler sat parked at a stop sign with its hazards on. Inside that Jeep: Harris, her boyfriend Cedric Johnson and her cousin Asia Humphrey.
- Miles didn’t initially stop at the Jeep, but Davis did. He danced to the front left of it. Then Johnson rolled the driver’s side backseat window down as Davis walked up and had a confrontation with Johnson. Testimony differed as to what exactly was said between the two, but Davis testified he called Johnson out to have a fist fight.
- Miles came back to the Jeep and pulled Davis away from the Jeep, Johnson testified. Eventually, the trio walked away from the Jeep.
- Miles had a “calming effect” on Davis, Bradley told police, per investigator testimony from 2023.
- Miles told police he saw a gun passed back to Johnson while at the Jeep. Johnson and Humphrey confirmed that during Davis’ trial. Johnson testified Harris slid him his gun after Davis told him he “whacks people.” Davis denied saying that during his testimony.
- Miles got Davis away from the Jeep because he saw the gun, Miles told police.
- Miles, Davis and Bradley walked behind the Houndstooth, back to Bradley’s car.
- At 1:38:30 a.m. Miller texted Miles to let him know he was on the way to pick him up from the Strip.
- Nine seconds later, Miles texted Miller “I need my joint. A (person) ‘rl jus got da fakin” as shown in court during Davis’ trial. Fakin’, Miller told the jury, meant “somebody was trying to scare somebody.” And joint is referring to Miles’ gun, an investigator testified in a prior hearing.
- During the trial last week, an attorney for Davis asked Miller, “when you received that text message, you knew Darius wanted that gun, it’s because someone is threatening him, right?” Miller answered “correct.”
- Miles got in the car with Bradley in his two-door Dodge Challenger and drove back to Grace Street. Meanwhile, Davis went “to look for the Jeep,” Bradley testified. “He was worried about the Jeep.”
- Miles and Bradley drove to Grace Street “to check on Buzz,” Bradley testified. Buzz is Davis’ nickname.
- Miles and Bradley parked on the right side of Grace Street. Miller pulled up behind them in his Dodge Charger and also parked.
- Miles walked up to Davis and Skylar Essex, Miles’ girlfriend. Then the three walked back to the two cars.
- Miles and Davis then walked to the back right of Miller’s car while Essex waited by Bradley’s car. Dash cam audio from Miller’s car made it possible to hear what Davis and Miles said in the back of the car. Testimony from Davis and a police investigator confirmed who said what.
- “The heat is in the hat,” Miles said.
- “Is there one in the head?” Davis responded.
- “You know it is,” Miles said.
- The conversation referred to a handgun and that a bullet was in the chamber, per testimony from an investigator.
- A police investigator testified in 2023 he relied on this conversation captured on the dash cam that Miles aided and abetted a capital murder.
- After Miles emerged from the back of the Dodge Charger, he walked back to his girlfriend who was standing at the front car. Davis went a different direction. Miles moved Essex and her friend off Grace Steet to an area behind the Houndstooth.
- “(Davis) told Darius to take me home,” Essex testified.
- Miles walked back toward Miller and Bradley’s cars on Grace Street. Then he walked by both cars, continuing to walk past the Jeep that had ended up right behind Miller’s car. The Jeep did not have its headlights on. Johnson testified that he switched them off about two minutes prior.
- Miles glanced into the Jeep when he walked by, Humphrey testified.
- Miles also flipped his hood on his jacket up when he walked by the Jeep. In that moment, Davis emerged from behind two buildings. Miles flipped the hood back down right after.
- Miles continued walking and disappeared from the view of surveillance cameras. He left the scene and was not on Grace Street when Davis ran up to the driver’s side window and shot into the Jeep.
- Miles’ next known action: He and Essex picked up Davis, who was on foot, after the shooting, Davis testified. They went back to Vie at University Downs, the apartment complex where they started the night.
- Davis testified he “gave (the gun) back to Darius Miles.” Davis also said he did not know what Miles did with the gun.
- Police investigator Branden Culpepper testified that the gun was found at the apartment where the group went before and after the time on the Strip. The gun was in a closet, in a drawer, wrapped in a Gatorade towel.
Nick Kelly is an Alabama beat writer for AL.com and the Alabama Media Group. Follow him on X and Instagram.
Read More