Former Montgomery cop to be freed from prison in shooting death after plea, attorney general says

Former Montgomery cop to be freed from prison in shooting death after plea, attorney general says

A white former Montgomery police officer convicted in the 2016 shooting death of a Black man will soon be getting out of prison.

A Dale County jury in 2019 convicted Aaron Cody Smith, 31, of manslaughter in the death of 59-year-old Gregory Gunn after an encounter in a Montgomery neighborhood on Feb. 25, 2016.

A judge sentenced Smith to 14 years in prison.

Smith is incarcerated at Limestone Correctional Facility.

The Alabama Supreme Court in 2022 rejected Smith’s appeal, and he filed a Rule 32 petition challenging his conviction.

Earlier this month, The Alabama Attorney General’s Office took over the case from the Montgomery County District Attorney’s Office with no explanation.

Smith’s Rule 32 petition was granted on Wednesday, and Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall announced he had reached a plea agreement with Smith.

“Mr. Smith pleaded to manslaughter and will now be released from prison on time served,’’ according to Marshall’s press release.

It was not immediately clear when Smith will be released.

Gregory Gunn (AL.com)

Marshall said the case first came to his office on appeal in 2020.

“Despite my personal misgivings about the strength of the case against Mr. Smith, my office successfully defended the conviction in accordance with our statutory duty,’’ he said.

“I then watched as the case went on to the Alabama Supreme Court and back again to the trial court late last year.”

Marshall said he believed Smith should get a new trial.

“But after eight years of watching this protracted litigation, I exerted my authority to bring this case to a close,’’ he said.

“Mr. Smith has pleaded guilty to the offense for which he was convicted, in exchange for returning to his family. I believe that this is a fair and appropriate outcome.”

Marshall said he spent time last week with the Gunn family.

“I am acutely aware of the pain and suffering they’ve experienced with the loss of their brother,’’ the attorney general said. “My heart goes out to them. I hope that they are able to find some closure and healing with this matter finally resolved.”

“My heart also goes out to the Smith family,’’ Marshall said. “Mr. Smith chose an honorable career of protecting the public and his life was shattered in an instant —a reality that all law enforcement officers today live in fear of. He has paid a high price. It is time for him to go home.”

Aaron Cody Smith

Montgomery police officer Aaron Cody Smith, center, arrives at a court hearing in Montgomery in March 2016.

According to the Court of Criminal Appeals account summarized in one of the Supreme Court justice’s written opinions, Gunn was on patrol in a high-crime neighborhood about 3 a.m. when he encountered Gunn, 58, who was walking.

Smith stopped Gunn for a pat-down. Gunn initially complied but broke away and ran.

Smith called for backup and tried unsuccessfully to stop Gunn with his Taser and his baton. Gunn ran onto the front porch of a home. When Smith pursued, Gunn charged at Smith with a painter’s pole.

Smith shot and killed Gunn. An autopsy showed Gunn was shot at least seven times, including three in the chest.

A Montgomery County grand jury indicted Smith for murder. His trial was moved to Dale County because of pretrial publicity.

Smith’s lawyers argued during the trial that Smith shot Gunn in self-defense and in the line of duty as a police officer.

Prosecutors said the evidence did not support the claim that Gunn posed a deadly threat to Smith.

Though indicted on a murder charge, the jury found Smith guilty on the lesser charge of manslaughter.