Asking Eric: Sister gets short end of the stick from father’s estate

Dear Eric: My dad passed away three years ago. He lived about 10 hours away from me but near my sister.

Sis and Dad have always been close. I had an OK relationship with both of them, though she and I have never been close. She took on most of his care and I tried to visit a few times a year.

Dad had a paid-off house worth about $250,000. To make probate easy, he “sold” the house to my sister when his health declined. He had said we were to sell the house and split it four ways between me, her and two step-siblings when he passed. Both steps had no contact with him for several years, so she asked me if I minded leaving them out. I said OK.

She sold the house, said she didn’t get much because of issues it had and sent me $10,000. I tried to be OK with this, but a bit more would have been nice. Yes, she deserved more for the time she put into his care.

I found out through a cousin that, after selling the house, my sister paid off her own house, bought her and her daughter brand-new cars and sent her grown daughter and grown grandchild on European tours. I think the part that gets to me is she lied to me. I guess she didn’t have to technically send me anything because it was in her name.

Maybe if she would have told me differently, I wouldn’t have minded as much. But telling me she didn’t get much out of the sale hurts knowing it had to have sold for more than $150,000. I just wonder now if I should say something to her? I am trying to be OK with this, but that was a slap in the face to me. Should I reach out, or let it lie?

– Left Out Sister

Dear Sister: First, the legal: you could, if you want, consult an estate attorney to see about the possibility of suing your dad’s estate. From your description, this could be tricky as much of what was agreed upon seems to have been spoken, instead of written, and the house was in your sister’s name. But if it’s bothering you, that is an option.

However, I think a conversation with your sister – whether or not you talk to an attorney – is going to be more productive. There are some parts of this story that you can check out on your own – the sale price, for instance. But it sounds like what you need most is a way to understand the new shape of your relationship with your sister. Yes, the money is important, but the grief from your father’s death and the confusion around the inheritance have created wounds that money wouldn’t fix. So, talk to your sister. Try to have a conversation that is focused less on accusation than it is on finding some peace for yourself and, perhaps, a new foundation for your relationship with her.

Read more Asking Eric and other advice columns.

Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at [email protected] or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110. Follow him on Instagram and sign up for his weekly newsletter at rericthomas.com.

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.